http://www.replacements.com/thismonth/archive/v1114g.htm
The ones like the smaller decanter I found were almost identical to yours !! May have had a slightly different pattern which is not unusual !! So for it I would go with the Victorian era barber bottle !! I saw several ll with the same ID !!
On the taller one by tail do you mean on the bottom ?? Take a pic looking straight on at the cameo but try to get the whole bottle in the pic !! I will see if Fostoria made one without her profile !!
Oh,, and when you answer do it on the “reply” rather than on the comments !! If you just comment it will not show up when I check the recent posts !!
OK,, I did some checking and found that Fostoria did make the bottle without the cameo before making the Jenny Lind !! Read he first paragraph on the link !! Jenny Lind was made 1954 to mid sixties so yours would have been made prior to that !! It did not say when it was made though !! Will look more !!
Does the tall one have the Jenny Lind profile in the cameo ?? The other one does not look like milk glass,, Just an inexpensive white glassware !! Is anything on the bottom of either one ??
Did some checking and some sites list the smaller bottle as Victorian era barber bottles !! Prices on the Jenny Lind around $25. and the smaller bottle about $20.
Thank you. No it does not have the Jenny lind that’s why I was not sure. It’s identical to in every other way. The bottom of the tall one looks like a sticker was there at one point. It has a very thin tail in the middle but was smoothed in while the glass was still heated (if that makes sense). The smaller one has nothing that can give me a hint as to what it is haha.