Collector Learns the Truth About Antique-Looking Artwork

   

Q: I wondered if you might have any information about this seemingly antique statue I’ve acquired. It depicts Christ and the Virgin Mary. The back is inscribed with the number “1796.” Thank you for your time and assistance.

A: Your statue is a stylized version of Michelangelo Buonarroti’s Pietà di San Pietro (1498–1499), which depicts the Virgin Mary cradling Jesus after his removal from the cross, representing her sixth sorrow. While Michelangelo created three distinct Pietàs—the Pietà di San Pietro, Pietà Bandini, and Pietà Rondanini—the Pietà di San Pietro remains the most iconic. The term pietà translates to pity in Italian. Your statue lacks information on dimensions or material composition but appears to be brown-stained plaster. Plaster was widely used in the 18th century for reproductions of classical sculptures, but your piece seems to be a poorly stained 20th-century copy, inscribed with a questionable date of “1796.” Based on its quality and apparent age, its value is estimated at $20–$25.

Our guest appraiser is Dr. Anthony Cavo, a certified appraiser of art and antiques and a contributing editor to Kovels Antique Trader. Cavo is also the author of Love Immortal: Antique Photographs and Stories of Dogs and Their People.

 

You May Also Like:

Villeroy & Boch: Looks Like a Fortune, Priced Like a Find

John Rogers Sculpture

Shrinking Statue

 

April Tip: Don’t be Fooled by Fakes

Dear Lee: You and I both like a good April Fool’s joke. When it comes to collectibles, though, we don’t want people to be fooled by fakes—and there are loads of them on the market. Here’s just a small sampling of fakes to watch out for: Coca-Cola signs. Some things to know: Coca-Cola never produced […]

Reproductions: Figural Napkin Rings

Napkin rings first appeared in France about 1800 and their use soon spread to other countries. In a proper middle-class family, cloth napkins were used for an entire week between washdays, with each family member keeping their same napkin. Each ring had a different mark or design to identify whose napkin it held. Soon napkin […]

Mickey Mouse Watch Repro

Something to watch out for. The original Mickey Mouse wristwatch, first made by Ingersoll in 1933, is being reproduced. It has a round dial with Mickey Mouse on the face, his arms serving as the watch’s hands and his yellow gloves pointing to the numbers. His feet are positioned just inside the numbers 5 and […]

Fake Fenton Art Glass — Tips on Spotting Reproductions

Reproduction or “Made in China” Fenton art glass has been appearing on online auction sites and even in antique store displays. You can spot the true art glass made by Fenton Glass artisans in America. Collectors should always look for Fenton glass marks, artist signatures and artistic style to determine if the piece is authentic. […]