Elmer’s Auto & Toy Museum Fabled Toy Collection Heads to Auction
WILLOUGHBY, Ohio—The legendary collection of toys from Elmer’s Auto & Toy Museum, Fountain City, Wis., heads to auction Saturday, Oct. 28, at Milestone Auctions. The event is the first in a multi-year series of quarterly sales of thousands of toys that enchanted museum visitors for nearly 30 years.
Elmer and Bernadette Duellman were married for 56 years and amassed one of the greatest auto and toy collections in the world. Elmer passed away in 2019. Image courtesy of the Duellman family
“We feel honored to be chosen by the Duellman family to represent Elmer’s incomparable collection,” Miles King, co-founder of Milestone Auctions, said. “We know the toy community is going to love what’s coming in each successive sale.”
“It’s impossible to describe how comprehensive Elmer’s collection is. He had a head start on all of us,” King said. “As far back as the 1980s, Elmer was buying and selling at a rapid pace and had a small army of pickers from coast to coast who were always on the lookout for items of interest.”
Duellman was also known for his encyclopedic knowledge of toys. He authored two volumes of the now-classic Elmer’s Price Guide to Toys and contributed significantly to Volumes 1 through 5 of the Evolution of the Pedal Car and Other Riding Toys.
I.Y. Japan tin friction Condor Motor Cycle, 12in long, all original and complete with rare original pictorial box. Estimate: $2,000-$4,000 Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
“Dad collected a lot of pressed steel toys and a lot of tin—Japanese, German, and American—and car-racing memorabilia and board games,” plus tether racers, Dinky Toys, TootsieToys, and ride-on toys,” said Les Duellman, the oldest of Elmer and Bernadette Duellman’s six children. “He always sought out original condition and original boxes because he knew that’s what really made the piece. He also liked boxed sets that were complete with all of their parts present, as well as ships, airplanes, and car and car-racing memorabilia and board games.”
Alps Japan tin friction Lincoln Futura, with original box. Estimate: $2,500-$3,500. Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
The initial 818-lot auction begins at 10 a.m. EST, Saturday, Oct. 28. You can preview the sale at the auction gallery, 38198 Willoughby Parkway, Willoughby, Ohio, during the week prior to the auction, and from 8-10 a.m. the day of the event. Bidding is live at the gallery, absentee, or live online through HiBid (via Milestone’s website), LiveAuctioneers, Invaluable, or AuctionZip.
For more information or to preview the auction catalog, go to Milestoneauctions.com or call 440-527-8060.
Other highlights from the auction include:
Original Buddy ‘L’ International Harvester ‘Red Baby’ express truck, pressed steel, 24 in. long. Excellent condition. Originally available only through International Harvester dealers, in very limited numbers. Estimate: $3,000-$5,000. Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
American National Packard Roadster pedal car, 29 in. long, beautifully restored with the dash in original condition. Estimate: $2,000-$4,000. Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
Bremer Whirlwind tether gas-powered race car. All original as-raced condition. Complete with motor, ignition, gas tank, and drive system. Estimate: $1,000-$1,500 Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
Metalcraft Airmail Toy Airplane with an electric motor that spins the propeller, with rare original box. Nicest example Milestone’s toy experts have seen. Estimate: $2,000-$3,000. Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
Rare I.Y. Japan tin friction Romance motorcycle, known to collectors as the ‘large blue version.’ Twelve inches long. Excellent condition. Estimate: $2,000-$3,000. Photo courtesy of Milestone Auctions
Whimsical windup toys first gained popularity in the 1800s, as large, windup automatons enjoyed by the wealthy gave way to smaller, affordable windups. A wide range of windup toys were up for grabs at a recent Pook & Pook Inc. auction in Pennsylvania. Top price was $8,540 for a Baranger Studios animated lovebird store window […]
Tin Toys
The earliest manufactured American toys were made of tin. Pieces of tin were cut by hand or machine, assembled, soldered, and painted by hand. Tinsmiths used their scrap pieces left over from making lanterns or cookie cutters to make toys. The first “factory” for tin toys opened in Meriden, Connecticut, during the 1840s. Other toymakers […]
Moving Toys
Clockwork toys were produced in quantity in America from about 1865 to 1900. The toys were quite literally made with brass clockworks on the inside to move the arms or legs of the toy. Moving toys were manufactured from painted or printed tin, wood, cast iron, or cloth. Dancing figures, walking figures, cigarette-smoking men, circus […]
Lithographed Tin Toys
Most lithographed tin toys found today were made between 1870 and 1915, although some were manufactured later. All sorts of wagons, fire engines, stagecoaches, and buses are valuable today; locomotives, trains, and horsecars are better; and old tin boats are the rarest. Collectors are especially interested in animated groups of animals or people; toys that […]
Popular Toys and Games Pre 1900
Most of the toys and games popular today were invented years ago. This table helps to date toys by furnishing the approximate dates some toys and games were first manufactured. Toys Starting Date of Commercial Manufacture Board games Late 18th century Cap guns and cap exploders Mid-19th century (most popular 1885-1915) Card games (Authors, Old […]
Tin Toys
Because the 19th-century Industrial Revolution resulted in new technology and the creation of a middle class, the invention of tin toys was possible and profitable. Earlier toys had been made of wood, fabric or ceramics. Tin toys were made in the early years of the 19th century in Germany, England and France. The J. Hess […]
Zeppelin Tin Toy
Q: My husband received this toy zeppelin when he was a young boy. It’s probably at least 65 years old. The box is in good condition and the wording on it says, No. 2017, Strauss Flying Zeppelin. The price on the back of the box is 48 cents. Can you tell me anything about it and what its worth?
A: Ferdinand Strauss was an importer in the early 1900s. He started his own toy company in East Rutherford, New Jersey, in 1914 when the outbreak of World War I in Europe made it impossible to import toys from Germany. The company was known for its mechanical tin toys. Zeppelins, the first rigid airships, were popular in the 1920s and 1930s. Strauss was granted patents for its toy zeppelins in 1926. Strauss was in business until 1942. Value of your toy and its original box, about $400-$500.
Tin Windups
Old toys seem more imaginative than new ones, even though they are often not considered safe by today’s standards. In the early 1900s, lithographed tin toys, especially those made in Germany, were popular. Many had moving parts, a comical look, bright colors and sharp edges. Today collectors keep old toys away from young children for […]
Antique Tin Toys
The government has strict rules about toys with tin parts that could cut a child. Many toys now have plastic parts. Collectors like the old tin toys, especially those that move. Most of the tin windup type toys were made from the 1920s to the 1950s. One popular toy made by Louis Marx Company and […]